Faculty Publications - The Dangerous Thirteenth Amendment

balkin_jack.jpg

What's dangerous about the Thirteenth Amendment's bar of slavery and involuntary servitude? In a Columbia Law Review essay YLS Prof. Jack Balkin and UT's Sanford Levinson argue that at the time of its prohibition in the Northwest Ordinance (from which the 13th Amendment is an almost verbatim copy) and as understood by the founders, "slavery" commonly referred not only to chattel slavery but encompased a broad range of forms of social domination. And unlike the 14th Amendenment, the 13th included no state action requirement. Dear lawyers, think of the possibilities!

In their review of why the 13th Amendment has come to be read more narrowly than the 14th Amendment and Bill of Rights, Balkin and Levinson discuss how the concept of slavery was limited during abolition to avoid comparisons to economic and political domination. Once chattel slavery was abolished, defenders of the status quo declared society "free" so that even today, labelling an injustice "slavery" is viewed as off the wall and even insulting to the memory of African-American slaves. The authors conclude by asking how our history might have been different if we hadn't lost the founding generation's conception of "slavery." 

Further reading:

Amy Dru Stanley, From Bondage to Contract: Wage Labor, Marriage, and the Market in the Age of Slave Emancipation (1998).

Eric Foner, Nothing But Freedom: Emancipation and Its Legacy (1983).

Jack M. Balkin, Corporations and the Thirteenth Amendment, Balkinization (Jan. 28, 2012).

Jack M. Balkin, More on Corporations as Slaves, Balkinization (Jan. 29, 2012).

 

 

Related News

This month marks the 50th anniversary of the death of Professor Alexander Mordecai Bickel, who served on the Yale Law faculty from 1956 until his...
News
Constitutional law is one of the selection foci of our domestic and foreign law collections with many titles authored by our faculty, students, alumni...
Dear 1Ls and Transfer Students, This is a reminder to register your Westlaw, Lexis Plus and Bloomberg Law passwords. Please first locate the...